Something has been stirring in me for a couple of years now. Which is to say that, while I am not an expert with an advanced degree in adoption, I do have some life experience which I think has earned me a right to speak.
And so I shall.
Before I ever adopted my girls, I started reading adoption blogs. And books. And anything else I could get my hands on regarding the topic. If I love something, I want to know everything I can about it. And I love adoption. (Even more than I love coffee! Please understand the magnitude of that statement, typed with my trusty mug only centimeters from my elbow.)
Most of what I read on the topic prior to starting my own journey, and most of what I have read since that time, has resonated with me. I find myself nodding in agreement and solidarity with other parents — usually moms– whose children have been born to them via airplanes and paperwork, rather than the more traditional route.
But there is one thing that hasn’t resonated. At all. To the point that it raises my hackles, causes a lump in my throat, and makes me want to… to… write about it.
And so I shall.
This thing — the one that has prickled, irritated, and bothered me, like a tiny pebble in my favorite wool clog — is the notion that adoption is somehow God’s Plan B for a child. That staying with a birth family is always God’s A game, but that when that doesn’t work out, God makes a new way — one that is somehow always inferior to a child living out his or her life in the biological and cultural setting where they started their days.
I just don’t believe that any more than I believe God always wants a girl to marry the first guy she thinks she loves. The notion that God’s plan is “always” the original one you see implies that our limited human vision is where it’s at.
It’s so not.
You see, I have two daughters. I fought hard to get to them. We didn’t take one look at each other and suddenly, to the accompaniment of heavenly angelic voices,become a harmonious family unit. I don’t believe in love at first sight. I never have. I believe that upon first seeing someone who is supposed to be yours, there is something that draws you to them. But love? Love takes more than that. Love takes time and it takes getting to know someone. In a biological situation, you have nine months with a child before you meet him or her. In an adoption situation you have nine months or more with… a picture… and a few words on paper. And you have dreams. And, whether you want to or not, you develop ideas about what your new child will be like. The actual child, on the other hand, is living a life wholly independent of you, often on the other side of the globe, in a different culture, usually in an institutional setting, and more often than not, with NO idea that a family is coming for him or her.
Simply put, you are about to rock that child’s world, and bring on a whole host of Big Feelings, some of which may well include fear, sadness, a sense of loss and just plain, scary, ugly grief. Which means that in many adoption situations, the entry phase to your new family life is rocky, awkward, and straight up unpleasant for one or more parties. And it may last days, weeks, months or possibly even years.
But does that mean it wasn’t meant to be? Of course it doesn’t! God has myriad ways of putting people in families. How and why he does it are a complete mystery to we who are not He.
As I said, I am not an expert in any academic sense, on the topic of adoption. But my real-life experience, times two, tells me that my girls and I were meant to be. From the dawn of time. Without question. I know this every time I look at them. I know this by the way my arms feel when I hold them. I know this as much and as well as I know that sunshine is warm, water is wet, and fire is hot.
My oldest daughter, the beautiful, exotic, fiery child from Eastern Europe who loves horses, and dogs, and school, who has the most amazing sense of empathy I have ever encountered, and whose strong will and determination will move mountains and, no doubt, change the world was my first evidence of this. She is amazing. She is funny. She has more passion about things than any person I have ever met. And, I say this absolutely without a shred of arrogance, she needed me to help her become the Clara God made her to be. I am able to say this because all I did was say “yes.” God made the plan. I stepped into it out of obedience and with more than a little fear and trembling.
When I first decided to adopt, I was so unsure of myself and… everything. The process. The outcome. Whether it would enhance my life or turn it forever on its head. And, after much prayer, I came to the realization that one of two things was true. Either God had my child already chosen and would cause our paths to cross, or He would give me the grace I needed to parent whomever I chose. And so I jumped in, praying hard the whole way, to something bigger than anything else I had ever done. And I went all the way through the process not knowing which of my theories was truth. It was an exercise in faith the likes of which I hadn’t experienced until that point.
And then she came home. We had some rough spots during our transition into a family, that fiery girl and I, along with our two dogs. It wasn’t always easy. In fact, the first year was hard. (I have blocked most of it, but have been reminded by friends who walked the path with me.) But, even through the rough stuff, it quickly became clear that she was mine. She was SO mine. She had always been meant to be — MINE. People who have known me for decades met Clara, laughed and said “Wow. That was so obviously meant to be.” Clara’s Grandpa David, after she had been home for a few years, jokingly commented “Clara is actually more Joleigh than Joleigh. She’s Joleigh squared!” My mom and dad look at each other, smile, laugh and say encouraging things like “Finally. You got yours.” This child. She is so much like her mama from the incessant chatter, to the imagination, to the eye rolling to the awkward snark.
My journey to my second daughter was a little more erratic. I had two little girls in two different countries picked out before I found her, neither of whom worked out. I was reading files like a crazy woman (very likely driving our Nina batty) and almost manic at points, in my effort to find her. And then one day, there she was. Off to the side in a photo of my friends’ little girl at her birthday party in the orphanage. Something about her spoke to me. I dismissed it until, a week or two later, her file showed up on Nina’s desk. A few short months after that, she was mine.
This little girl had lived a rocky existence prior to becoming my daughter, and she had a lot of trauma to process. This caused a super difficult start to our relationship — one that has taken nearly a full year to work through. (I will be candid, this is mostly on my part as she has been doing well for a lot longer than that.)
BUT. All of the hard — and it has been HARD – doesn’t mean it wasn’t meant to be.
You see, had my girls stayed in the lands of their birth, with the women who gave birth to them, their futures would have been bleak. One would likely have been begging on the street at a very early age, exposed to God knows what, a member of a very despised minority in her country. The other would have grown up in a place where she was cast aside due to factors surrounding her birth. While not impossible, it is very unlikely that either would have flourished.
And so here I sit, as their mama in every single way possible, except for the biological one, watching them not just survive, but thrive. Watching them learn, and grow. Watching them become the sisters I believe they were always meant to be — fiercely loyal to one another while still driving each other just crazy enough to make them “real” sisters. I hear them giggle. I watch them build relationships with other people who love them nearly as fiercely as I do. I watch them hop on and off the bus that takes them to a school where they are nurtured and adored. And where they learn — alongside peers of both sexes and varying skin tones, none of them considered “less than” because of race or gender. I watch one as she becomes a pretty solid little horse woman and discovers that she wants to play the guitar, while the other one just longs to dance and make music, in between putting together elaborate puzzles that still don’t interest her sister who is three years older.
I am watching them live. I am watching them become. I am watching God’s plan for those two girls unfold daily. I am nurturing them. I am loving them more than life. And as I do all of that my heart — in fact every cell in my body – screams “There is no way this is anyone’s Plan B.”